A Note from James: I will no longer be rating by stars, or any other quantitative system. It’s an awfully rigid way to measure a fluid, dreamlike medium.
Summary: A solid, fun fantasy film with impressive performances, Marvel’s best cinematic villain to date, and the promise of a lot more to come.
Review: Through its recently formed Studios branch, comic book giant Marvel is putting together the most ambitious sci-fi/fantasy effort since Peter Jackson’s ‘The Lord of the Rings’ trilogy. Four superheroes — Iron Man, The Hulk, Captain America, and Thor — are getting solo cinematic treatments, then being tied together in next year’s ‘The Avengers’, which is shooting under Joss Whedon’s direction now. While Captain America has yet to debut, Iron Man and The Hulk performed well, and now the burden falls to Thor.
With a rich fantasy backstory drawn from Norse mythology comes an inherit risk of camp. Director Kenneth Branagh and Marvel’s team of writers crafted an effective, if not terribly fresh, story, but what sells the film is its leads. Newcomer Chris Hemsworth — who previously provided a tear-jerkingly heroic performance as George Kirk in J.J. Abram’s ‘Star Trek’ — simply kicks ass as Thor. He’s a miraculously good actor, someone who can sell subtle emotional changes and go toe-to-toe with great hams like Sir Anthony Hopkins.
Natalie Portman is his earthbound love interest, physicist Jane Foster, and she refuses to play her as a typical determined scientist, instead letting her dissolve into a giggling schoolgirl around Thor, an amusing and sympathetic reaction. Given her brief screentime, she deserves a good deal of praise.
Of course, no comic book film excels without a good villain, and the true distinctive of ‘Thor’ is Tom Hiddleston’s Loki. He’s a truly Shakespearean baddie, a guy who thinks of himself as the hero of his story, a good guy gone bad by going mad. While another villain might cackle and spit out threats with an uncompromised glee, Loki actually weeps when he confronts his heroic brother in the final battle, even as he laughs and snarls and throws down with the best of them. He’s a manipulative liar, but he believes he’s doing the right thing, and we feel his pain.
Most of the film takes place on a cosmic stage, as war brews between noble Asgard and bitter Jotunheim, the home of the Frost Giants. With fantastic CGI and refreshingly tangible sets, I found myself believing in it. The action has a real weight to it, and while Branagh isn’t the best action director around, he and his team still know that matters is clarity and impact. When it desperately needs to work, it does. This isn’t the best superhero action, but it is on a larger canvas than most, and deserves recognition.
As excited as I am for ‘The Avengers’, even if that wasn’t on the horizon, I’d be game for a ‘Thor’ sequel, a chance to cut loose from the trappings of an origin story and really let the “God of Thunder” loose in an even bigger conflict. I really hope they do.